In older D&D, characters get by cleverness (player skill) or by luck (die rolls), but even when we first meet them, the likes of Conan, Fafhrd & Gray Mouser, Ganelon, and Skafloc are skilled, puissant sorts. One might quibble regarding Fafhrd and Gray Mouser. Tthey are presented in the chronologically earlier but written later Leiber stories "Snow Women" and the "Unholy Grail," as youths, but they seem to be pre-hero (call it 0 level) in those, to me. We are told that Conan, in contrast, was formidable even at a young age: "I was one of the horde that swarmed over the hills. I hadn't yet seen fifteen snows, but already my name was repeated about the council fires."
There is fiction more representative of these early level adventurers perhaps as likely to come to ruin as to succeed, but we don't find it as much in heroic fantasy as in other genres. Fairytales and legends with their less competent protagonists often have heroes escaping by cleverness or luck or Providence --or not escaping and meeting a bad end. Picaresque adventure novels and some novels in the Gothic tradition often have protagonists buffeted from one predicament to another and seldom do they get out of them due to their adventuresome capabilities!
While not as violent as D&D or as some older fairytales, the Oz novels have protagonists engaging in exploration, encountering dangers, and mostly having combat being a fail-state.
This sort of plot where characters either narrow escape (or fail to escape) does show up in fantasy, too. Lord Dunsany (who is in Appendix N) and Clark Ashton Smith have stories of this sort. Mignola and collaborators have created some stories in the style of these two masters in Bowling for Corpses and Other Strange Tales from Lands Unknown and Uri Tupka and the Gods.
Are there any of the most frequently cited Appendix N authors and works that depict these sort of characters? I think so. Jack Vance with Eyes of the Overworld and Cugel's Saga, certainly, and Tolkien's The Hobbit.
As I mentioned, initially thinking of Greyhawk as a more firmly Medieval place was the impetus for this series, but as these things tend to do, my approach has drifted some with time. While my view remains more realistically Medieval elements are nice to bring in, I also don't want to lose site of the Gygaxian Implied Setting Recipe, because at the end of the day, a Greyhawk that feels like Greyhawk (if more rationalized) is more interesting to me than a straight pseudo-history.
Fiction:As I previously mentioned, Cairn arrives at the end of spring, so we’ll make things easy and say it’s the first day of summer. It’s about 60 miles from Stonehold (where Cairn is from) to Daggerford, but that’s assuming a straight line. I would think that the primary road would head west from Stonehold to the river, and then follow the river north, crossing at some point to get to Daggerford. I would assume there are several villages and small keeps along the river where the caravan would stop to barter for a day or two - probably stopped ten times, so two days of rest and one day of travel would be thirty days since he left Stonehold. Paid a silver a day for guard duty would put him at the 3 gold he has in pocket, so that all lines up.
I’m going to say that Daggerford is a walled town of about 100 buildings and about 1,200 people. The people are exceedingly superstitious and gossipy. Daggerford was a small fishing village until 70 years ago when the survivors of Trasik arrived, and the village blossomed into a town virtually overnight. The majority of structures are less than 70 years old, but the roughly two dozen older structures stand out in contrast with the newer buildings.
I had actually written up a bit of information on Daggerford already, so I made a few minor edits to that, but it gives me a foundation to work from.
The first stop is the tavern. Cairn will spend 1 gold there to get some food and drink, and to see if he can get some information about Trasik (at a minimum) and his uncle (if he gets really lucky).
What is up with Trasik? I guess the first thing to determine is who lived there, and then what happened to it that it’s in ruins…
Was it humans? Likely. 8. Yes.
Was the purpose of the city mining? Possible. 6. Yes.
Copper mines? 7. No.
Iron? 9. No.
Salt? 3. Yes.
The Salt Mines of Trasik. Has a nice ring to it.
What happened?
Dragon Attack? 9. No.
Humanoid Siege? 11. No.
Evil Awakened? 10. No.
Combined event? 3. Yes.
So, the mines started to tap out of salt, deeper excavations opened a portal to the Vale of Eternal Winters, allowing wintry beasts to come through and ravage the town, sending the survivors fleeing. It was rumored that the more powerful salt guilds of the town had amassed great wealth that was lost or left behind, and may still be in these ruins. The town is now enveloped in an unending winter.
Let’s see how much of this Cairn learns. It’s a Mind check (yuck). He gets +1 edge from the gold he spent. I roll a 10 and an 8. Success! He basically learns everything I’ve written above. It is unlikely he also is able to get information about his uncle; I roll a natural 1!
Well then. It turns out that his uncle had made the Blind Basilisk his base of operations, and had reserved a room there permanently (paying 1,000 gold to reserve it ‘for 99 years’). He had made a half dozen successful forays to the ruins until two years ago when he stopped returning. The innkeeper allows him to use the room (since he has provided sufficient evidence that he is the nephew - and he assumes that the uncle is dead at this point).
I’m going to say that the room has a level 2 treasure left therein… I roll terribly, but still decide there must be at least one instance of treasure. There are three things in the chest: 14 gold, a key, and a journal that is written entirely in the dwarven tongue. I have him trade in his light hammer (gets 1 gold) and buy a medium hammer 4 (8 gold), leaving him with 9 gold. It is likely (if not very likely) that the key is to a chest that the uncle has hidden (containing his actual wealth), and this money was just pocket change he left here. If Cairn trades in his leather armor (getting 2.5 gold), he has enough to buy a ringmail shirt (leaving him with 1 gold and 5 silver). He does all this.
Cairn Torvinson of Clan Thunderforge, Jovial Dwarf Myrmidon 1
Armor 2; Hits 12; Move 60’; Hammer (5) and Shield (2)
Might 4; Mind 1; Reflex 1
Brawler; Fortitude; Two Weapons; Warrior
Ringmail Armor 2; Shield; War Hammer 4; 1 gold, 5 silver
He attacks at +2 with melee weapons, and deals +1 damage. He attacks with both hammer and shield each round. The shield grants +1 edge to armor checks.
The Journal…
I’m going to roll D12 to see how much awesome stuff is in the journal. On a 1, it is mostly personal entries about how he’s feeling, general “I destroyed three skeletons today” entries, and reflections on food or the people of Daggerford. With a 12, there are detailed maps of the ruined town, notes about caverns under the town he has explored, and with a natural 12 details on where he has hidden the chest.
Dang. I roll a natural 12. Alright then!
He learns that Toren had buried the chest at the back of a cave on the opposite side of the river, about a mile upstream. He has a drawing of what the cave looks like. The journal implies that the key is for the chest.
Toren had found a gap in the north wall of Trasik, and used this to venture in and out of the ruins.
He had a lair in Trasik - he found a house with a hidden cellar, and used the cellar as a place to rest and recover. He had taken extra measures to hide the cellar entrance, and in the several months the journal covers, he had made dozens of forays into the town.
His most recent entries were about the ‘frozen portal’, and how he had discovered a way past it. His final entry suggests he was attempting to get through the portal.